English translation
[4300]... - (...) It was narrated from Firâs with the chain of Shu'bah and Abû 'Awânah (a Hadîth similar to no. 4299). As for the Hadîth of Ibn Mahdî, it says: "Without him having done anything to deserve it". In the Hadîth of Wakî' it says: "Whoever slaps his slave" and does not mention "Without him having done anything to deserve it."
